STYLES
Nativity Scene Styles
There’s no single kind of nativity scene. Each style grew out of a place, a time and whatever people had on hand. Picking a style before you buy a single figure helps you avoid the most common mistake: a nativity that mixes everything and ends up looking like nothing in particular.
Why choose a style
A style is more than decoration. It’s a set of choices that work together. The lighting of a Neapolitan nativity doesn’t suit an Alpine one. The cypress trees of a Provençal crèche look odd in the snow. And a 6-inch dressed figure next to a 3-inch clay santon clashes in both size and material.
Your style decides the buildings, the colors, the plants, the size of the figures and the lighting. Choose it first and you’ll save yourself years of trial and error.
The five main styles
| Style | Hallmark | Palette | Difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Provençal | The whole village, its trades, its characters from the pastorale | Ochers, earth tones, the gray-green of olive trees, sky blue | Moderate: lots of figures to collect |
| Neapolitan | Ancient ruins, stairways, dressed figures, tavern scenes | Rich, contrasted, gilding and fabrics | High: buildings and sewing |
| Mountain | Wood, slopes, fir trees, snow | Warm browns, off-whites, dark green | Low to moderate: just a few elements |
| Church | Large scale, seen from a distance, kept simple | Deliberately limited | High: logistics and safety |
| Family | Made together, imperfect, added to every year | Whatever you have | None, and that’s the point |
These five don’t cover everything. The Polish szopka, the Catalan pessebre, the Latin American nacimiento, the Pennsylvania putz and Alsatian or Flemish nativities are styles of their own. See the nativity beyond Europe.
How to choose yours
Ask yourself four questions, in this order:
-
How much room, and for how long?
A full Provençal crèche needs room and takes years to build up. A mountain nativity fits on a dresser and can be finished in one winter.
-
Do you like building, or collecting?
If you love building, try the mountain or Neapolitan style, where the scenery is the star. If you love collecting, go Provençal: the fun is in the characters.
-
Who will be looking at it?
Kids love details and stories, so the Provençal village is hard to beat. Grown-ups walking past take in the big picture, so mountain and Neapolitan scenes make a stronger impression.
-
What comes from where you live?
This is the most interesting question. Every tradition has set the scene in its own local landscape. A Southwestern adobe nativity, a New England barn or a Pennsylvania putz is just as valid. See the family nativity.
Not sure, and it’s your first one? Start small, with a mountain or family nativity. Both are forgiving and inexpensive, and they’ll show you what you like before you commit to a collection. See your first nativity scene.
Mixing, when it works
Mixing styles usually fails for one reason: two styles side by side clash. It works when you keep them apart.
- Use the terrain. A Provençal village down low, a mountain sheep barn up high, and a pass between them. The distance makes the difference believable.
- Use one material. If every figure is unpainted bisque, you can mix characters from any tradition. The shared material ties it all together.
- Use scale. Put smaller figures from another style in the background. See can you mix sizes?
What doesn’t work: two styles side by side, at the same size, on the same path.